Unemployment: We're On Our Own

The President is scheduled to make a major address on jobs and job creation this evening. He is going to unveil his plan for reducing the unemployment rate below the 9% level where it seems to be stuck. I plan to be doing something else during the speech, maintaining my near unbroken, bipartisan record of skipping presidential addresses.

President Obama will probably propose a bold new program of infrastructure rebuilding. This will be combined with tax credits for companies that hire new employees and maybe a request for money to retrain displaced workers. This will be combined with lines like “let’s get this country moving again.”

The problem is that almost none of what he proposes is going to work. Tax credits have been tried before, and failed miserably, during the Carter administration. A $500 credit, or even a $1000 credit, simply is not enough incentive to convince employers to add on employees they don’t need. Conversely, if you do need to hire someone, you are going to do it whether tax credits are available or not.

Retraining sounds like a good idea, but community colleges are set up to produce entry level employees with no experience. Taking a couple of classes for six months to a year will not lead to a new career.

As for a massive Federal jobs program, that is going to run into fiscal realities. The government is spending 40% more than it is taking in tax revenue. A bipartisan super committee of Congressmen and Senators is currently doing the planning for a major round of spending cuts.

Besides, what does an infrastructure rebuilding program really consist of? A bunch of work crews filling potholes and painting bridges. Does anybody really think that an unemployed office worker who’s a hundred pounds overweight is going to take a job on a road crew? Those positions would probably be filled by illegal immigrants with fake social security numbers.

Nope, a big jobs program is an idea that would be dead on arrival. All that’s left is a bunch of high sounding phrases about how the government is no going to abandon the people who need help in this crisis.

Now, it is easy for me to be blasé about the unemployment rate. After all, I still have a job. But it seems to me that the best thing the President can do about jobs in this country is tell the truth: we’re on our own. It is not the Federal government’s responsibility to provide jobs. Even if it was, deficit spending has reached its limit and beyond.

Anybody who is waiting for the Feds to ride in like the cavalry and create a bunch of jobs is going to be sorely disappointed. The first step to solving a problem is to admit that the problem exists. Everybody agrees that high unemployment is a problem. But the second step towards solving a problem is taking ownership of the problem. As long as we think it is the President’s, or Congress’s, or the Federal government problem to solve unemployment, people will not take whatever necessary steps to reinvent themselves and find work.

You see, it is up to us, to get this country moving again.