BankTracker: How bad is it at my bank?

I have found a new toy. The BankTracker website has been set up to use publicly available data to rate the health of banks. The site takes information that banks are required to report to the FDIC every quarter, and creates a ratio of troubled assets to capital and reserves.

The troubled assets are defined as loans that have not received a payment in 90 days, loans that are no longer accruing interest (usually this means loans that have not received a payment in 60 days), and the category of other real estate, which means property that the bank has already foreclosed on. The foreclosed property is carried on the books as having a value equal to the outstanding balance of the loan at the time of foreclosure.

The troubled assets are then divided by the combination of Tier 1 capital and loss reserves to come up with a ratio. On the BankTracker website, the ratio is expressed as the percentage of troubled loans to capital. For example, if a bank had $100 million in capital and $10 million in troubled loans, the website reports the ratio as 10. If the website reported the ratio as 130, that would mean that troubled loans were equivalent in value to 130% of the banks capital.

So go ahead and look up your bank and see where they stand. I did, and my bank’s ratio was about 30. Their problem loans add up to about 30% of their capital. Not that bad, although the median for all banks was about 10. Still, my bank has enough capital to ride out the current mess, as long as the number of problem loans doesn’t get worse.

Even banks with ratios over 100 can still survive. If a bank has problem loans in excess of the amount of capital they carry, and cannot recover any of the value of those loans, the bank is technically insolvent. But that doesn’t take into account the recovery value of the assets. Take the other owned real estate (foreclosed properties). If the bank sells those properties for 50 cents on the dollar, they only write off half the value of the property.

For all of the problem loans, they will move from non accruing status to 90 days late, into foreclosure. After foreclosure, they will be other owned real estate. Eventually, the foreclosed houses will sell, and whatever fraction of the loan value the bank recovers will be added to capital.

I don’t know what criteria the FDIC uses to determine their problem bank list. But I would guess that anyone with a problem loan to capital ratio exceeding 150% would be an excellent candidate.